Debate is a Dirty Word {Ryan Knapp}

by Samantha on May 6, 2010

The ultimate authority must always rest with the individual’s own reason and critical analysis.
Dalai Lama

Last night, my wife and I watched the documentary ‘Lord: Save Us From Your Followers’ (which I absolutely highly recommend, by the way. It’s on-demand on Netflix).

The documentary was written and produced by Dan Merchant, who is Catholic.  Merchant travels around and tries to do something that is novel in the United States: Have a discussion / healthy debate about religion.

I always appreciate a healthy debate, whether it be about religion, sports, education, or the topic of your choice.

The problem with healthy debate is it requires you to, not only have a position on a topic, but also hear out the other side (side note: hearing out does not mean believing in it yourself).

Debate opens our eyes and our ears to topics and viewpoints we would have otherwise ignored.  It allows you to broaden your horizons and hear exactly why someone else believes in what they believe, without being preached at or converted (because that is NOT debate).

Living abroad, I was taught to avoid any discussions of American views, for fear of getting into a bad situation. Instead, I embraced talk of why non-Americans felt the way they did about our country, and learned quite a lot from my debates and discussions.

We are taught early on to avoid discussion on religion, politics, race and other hot-button topics in our society for fear of offending others.  Isn’t it ironic the topics which we are taught to avoid are the ones that cause the greatest divide?  If we were all more open about these topics, we’d learn a lot about each other and a lot about ourselves as well.

Educate yourself, take a stance, think critically, and then seek out others who oppose your view, and learn from them.

I appreciate those who disagree with me, who challenge me to learn more about myself by engaging in discussions that challenge my beliefs and make me a better person.

The next time you meet someone who has an opposite viewpoint, take the time to engage them in some healthy debate and discussion. You may be surprised what you learn.

Appreciative Revolutionary: Ryan Knapp (@ryanknapp)

Bio: Ryan Knapp is the founder and director of buffalofutsal where he gives everyone the opportunity to create memories by playing the beautiful game. When he’s not playing soccer, he’s probably our for a swim, a bike or a run.  Follow him and connect with him at www.ryanjknapp.me.

Favorite ice cream flavor: Birthday Cake Remix

I appreciate Ryan’s kind heart and his positive attitude and outlook on life!

Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • http://www.smallhandsbigideas.blogspot.com Grace Boyle

    Ryan, this is such great advice and I love the way you ended it: “The next time you meet someone who has an opposite viewpoint, take the time to engage them in some healthy debate and discussion. You may be surprised what you learn.”

    Avoidance gets us nowhere. Engaging and interacting (no matter the viewpoint) helps us to continually learn and expand our horizons. I think a lot of people are afraid of confrontation so it doesn't go anywhere. In addition, a lot of people say “No, my way is the only way,” making for a debate that isn't really a debate. That attitude frustrates me…but again, we can only control ourselves, right?

    Great post, Ryan!

  • emilyjasper

    I'm all for debate, but I often try not to get into ones where I don't have a leg to stand on. Instead, like you, I want to learn more about the other sides. I'm not sure if then I'm actually participating in the debate or more moderating/interviewing, but I learn so much that way. I don't like when people won't listen, however. You don't have to change your mind, but to blow off the other party just because it's not your turn to talk anymore is childish. Nice post!

  • http://www.bflofutsal.com/ryanknapp/ Ryan Knapp

    Thanks Emily. Yeah, debate where you don't have a chance really isn't debate, for me it's more like learning. I've got into plenty of discussions where I realized I know jack about the topic at hand. In those cases, I just ask open ended questions and use it as a learning experience for the future.

    Part of a discussion/debate is listening, and that is the part most people have a problem with. Anyone can talk, talk, talk, but it's different to listen, and to respond directly to what the other person is saying instead of speaking in generalizations.

  • http://www.bflofutsal.com/ryanknapp/ Ryan Knapp

    Thanks for the comments grace! Avoidance does get us nowhere. And confrontation is a fear that many of us have (myself included). I'm constantly afraid that disagreeing with someone will immediately sour any sort of progress that I've made and it will end badly.

    But I've learned and continue to learn this is not the case. And if that does happen, it's not worth it in the end!

    Thanks for the comment!

Previous post:

Next post: